Let me tell you a story about privilege and profiling that
might help with your understanding of what’s going down in Baltimore, and so
many other places.
I used to work downtown.
I was the acting Director of Vehicle Maintenance for the City of
Seattle, and my office was on the 52nd floor of the Seattle
Municipal Tower, known in those days as Key Tower from the previous owner,
Herman Sarkowsky, who sold it to the city but kept the penthouse for
himself. From my sealed window I could
look out to the south over the International District and Sodo, and when the
wind blew the building rocked and rolled.
My daughter had a back office job for the Bank of America at
that time, working on the 10th floor of an office tower just two
blocks north of me on 5th Avenue.
We had a regular habit of meeting for lunch every Wednesday in front of
her building, which was controlled access with a large customer service counter
just inside the main entrance with security people on duty. You had to pass by them to get to the
elevators, and you needed a badge to use them.
Typical of many downtown office buildings, the ground floor extends off
to one side to meet up with an underground tunnel across the street, with a
deli on the main floor and a small waiting area with seats under the direct
gaze of the counter.
Outside, the front plaza is connected to an outdoor
mezzanine on the south side, which includes a covered area for employees to
take their lunch breaks and a smoking section - before such criminality was
outlawed in Seattle - by an escalator moving in both directions along a
stairway favored by the younger athletic types.
I quickly found it amusing to wait for her by riding the escalator up
and down for a few minutes, and she learned to look for me there first when her
elevator disgorged a flock of her and her co-workers.
Those of you who know me would not be too surprised to
imagine me in business casual attire, which was expected of a bureaucrat of my
level with 15 supervisors and 125 employees, and typically would include
Dockers or similar slacks, nice shoes and a button collar shirt with a nice
jacket or sport coat and a tie (!), unlike my usual attire of jeans and biker
t-shirts if not riding gear or slacker shorts and Tevas. I still have those work clothes. I pull them out every now and then and spit
on them. But I admit they were enough to
detract from the big guy look with the full beard so that I was never bothered
by the security types after I stopped in the first time and told them who I was
waiting for.
So one day, when the wind blew and the rain came down
sideways, I was out there like usual, riding the escalator up and down, killing
time. The difference was, on this day I
was wearing an Aussie Duster coat in deference to the weather, one of those
full length coats in leather or heavy waxed outdoor fabric and a built-in cape
that, along with the waist belt, shoulder epaulets and trim look like something
out of the wild west (which indeed it is) and, on me, with a black leather hat
on top, could possibly be considered, ahem, intimidating.
So there I am, about to turn at the top and head back down
the escalator, when suddenly appeared a young, earnest Security Guard in full
uniform complete with radio and mace on his belt, asking if he can be of any
assistance.
I smiled at him and said, “I come here every Wednesday to
meet my daughter for lunch, who works on the 10th floor. I've been doing this regularly for the last
six months or so, but only now do you want to know if you can help me? Tell me, what is it that made you decide to
talk to me now? Was it the coat?” He stammered and blushed and assured me that
it was just a random coincidence, nothing to be concerned about, and beat a
hasty retreat. I had just been
profiled. Some security person had
noticed me riding the escalator, and, strictly because of my appearance,
assigned me potential threat status and pushed an alarm button. The weather improved, and the next week I was
back out there in my normal getup, and nothing was said or done.
So what does this have to do with Baltimore, or Ferguson, or
Brooklyn? Nothing, and everything. My experience on the escalators of the Bank
of America Building on 5th and Marion in downtown Seattle is a
simple experiment that any of you can perform any time you want. Just show up there looking like some kind of
a lowlife, or a bum, or a pickpocket, or, heaven help us, a biker, and see how
quick you draw a response. That’s the
security people’s job, to identify threats and respond. Take two kids and ride the escalator all day,
and you’ll not get challenged.
Now, imagine how it would feel if changing your clothes made
no difference. What if, no matter what
you did, or wore, the minute you started riding up and down that escalator the
security guard was going to be right there, wanting to know what you’re up
to? What if it was the color of your
skin that set off alarm bells in the security guard brains? And that simple question, my friends, is the
essence of white privilege. Us white
folks know, in the back of our minds at all times, that any cop or security guard
that looks at us will assume the best, unless we’re dressed like a beggar or a
biker and look the part. Even then, the
last thing we would expect an officer to do, and the most shocking thing they
could do, would be to pull a weapon on us.
What if that was the most likely thing to expect in any encounter? What if it happened over and over again,
every single time? How would you feel
about that? What if, every time you
turned around, somebody just like you got killed by the police? Can you imagine living in a society where that
would ever happen? Like the old guy who
was walking down the road on a charity errand the other day, swinging a golf
club. He got arrested for being a black
man with an obvious weapon. How many of
us white folks would stop for one second to think, “Gee, maybe I better not
take my golf club with me, some cop might decide it’s a weapon”, before heading
out for a walk in the park?
Now, imagine you’re a young black man, and you've grown up
in the inner city where life is hard all the time and nobody wants to hire you,
and your history and the history of all your people is a history of slavery,
lynching, Jim Crow, and discrimination, and you know, deep down inside, just
like the white folks know that the cops will assume they are the good guys, you
will be assumed to be the bad guy.
Imagine living under that, if you can, and it might start to make sense
that every now and then people who live like that tend to explode. It’s called, “don’t give a fuck”, and people
adopt it when their backs are on the wall.
It’s not your fault, directly, but you still have to pay the bill. So what can any of us do? Got any ideas? :-{)}